Blame the Throne, Not the Chromosome
Men Start All Wars
3/5The canard
“All wars have been started by men.”
Someone tell Catherine the Great, who waged wars of conquest for sport. The honest version: wars are started by whoever holds power — and for most of history that was men because they kept women off the throne, not because of a chromosome.
The receipts
'All wars have been started by men' mistakes who held power for what causes war. Wars are launched by states and rulers, and rulers were overwhelmingly men because men monopolized political and military office and shut women out — not because maleness causes war. Women who did reach power launched and led wars too, and the real drivers of war are political and structural. It's a tidy slogan that collapses on a single counterexample.
- 1
Wars are declared by states and the people who run them — and for nearly all of recorded history those people were men, because men monopolized political and military office and barred women from power (most women could not even vote until the 20th century). So 'the war-starters were men' describes who was permitted to hold power, not a property of the male sex. Correlation with a throne is not causation by a chromosome.[1]
- 2
'All' is doing the heavy lifting, and it is false: women who reached power have started and led wars across history. Catherine the Great launched wars of imperial expansion (the Russo-Turkish wars and the partitions of Poland); Boudica led a massive war against Roman Britain; in modern times leaders such as Indira Gandhi and Margaret Thatcher took their nations into war. One woman starting one war already breaks the rule — and there are many.[2][3][4]
- 3
War has causes, and 'maleness' is not one historians or political scientists list. Wars are traced to power and territory, resources, security fears, ideology, religion and economics — the situations states find themselves in, not the hormones of whoever signs the declaration. 'Men are just innately warlike' is an essentialist just-so story, and pinning a species-wide behaviour on one sex is exactly the kind of group caricature this project exists to flag.[5]
Sources
- [1]Women's suffrage — WikipediaDocuments that women were broadly excluded from the vote and from political office until the 19th-20th centuries — i.e. men held political and military power not by nature but because women were shut out of it.
- [2]Catherine the Great — WikipediaEmpress of Russia (r. 1762-1796) who pursued wars of imperial expansion, including the Russo-Turkish wars and the partitions of Poland — a woman head of state initiating wars.
- [3]Boudica — WikipediaQueen of the Iceni who led a large-scale war/uprising against the Roman occupation of Britain c. 60-61 CE — a woman initiating and commanding a major war.
- [4]Indira Gandhi — WikipediaPrime Minister of India who led the country through the 1971 Indo-Pakistani War — a modern example of a woman leader prosecuting a war.
- [5]War (nature and causes) — Encyclopaedia BritannicaOverview of the causes and theories of war — political, economic, territorial, ideological and structural factors — none of which reduce war to the sex of the decision-maker. (Britannica blocks automated scrapers but resolves normally in a browser.)
Send the duck
Drop this link under the post, or export a card for your story.
Paste the link under the post. It unfurls into a card; the page does the rest.
More canards to send
The Hummus Heist
“Israelis and Jews stole Arab food like hummus and falafel — they have no cuisine of their own.”
They Stole the Music Too?
“Israelis and Jews stole Arab music.”
But I Am a Semite Too
“I cannot be antisemitic — I am an Arab, so I am a Semite myself.”
This page debunks a false claim using sourced evidence. The target is the claim — never any person or community. Sources are linked above so you can verify every point yourself.